Code Review Checklist

Code Review Checklist

A practical code review checklist for engineering teams: correctness, readability, tests, security, performance and maintainability, with an interactive version.

Short answer: A good code review checks six things: correctness, readability, tests, security, performance and maintainability. Keep pull requests small, review within a day, and focus comments on real risks. Use the 18-item checklist below for each pull request.

Interactive code review checklist

Tick each item as you review. Progress saves only on this screen.

Correctness

Readability

Tests

Security

Performance

Maintainability

How to run a good code review

StepWhat to doWhy
1. Read the ticketUnderstand the goal before reading code.Judges the change against intent
2. Check sizeAsk to split pull requests over about 400 lines.Small reviews catch more issues
3. Run itPull the branch or check the preview build.Finds what reading misses
4. Review by areaGo through the checklist areas in order.Keeps reviews consistent
5. Comment clearlyMark comments as blocking or a suggestion.Speeds up the author
6. Approve or request changesApprove when blocking issues are fixed.Keeps work moving

Code review etiquette

  • Comment on the code, not the person
  • Explain why, and suggest a fix
  • Praise good solutions too
  • Use automation for style, so people focus on logic
  • Reply to every comment before merging

Bottom Line

Small pull requests, a shared checklist and clear comments make reviews fast and useful. Automate style checks and spend human time on logic, security and design.

Building a remote team? Every Staffenza engineer passes a live technical interview. See how to manage remote developers or talk to us.

Code Review FAQs

How long should a code review take?

Aim to respond within one working day. Small pull requests take minutes to review.

How big should a pull request be?

Keep it small enough to review in one sitting, roughly under 400 changed lines.

Who should review code?

At least one engineer who knows the area. Seniors should also review critical changes.

What should be automated?

Formatting, linting, tests and security scans should run in CI before human review.